Causes of Poverty in Africa: Lost Continent or Land of Opportunities?
Excluding Africa from the rest of the world
In fact, there has been some growth since 1995 but it's been mostly in the very new services sector so it created only a few jobs whereas manufacturing and agriculture could have done much better.
As the British prime minister declared in 2001 African poverty is "a scar on the conscience of the world". In recent years, globalization and technological inflation have made it only worse. It only helped further excluding the continent and widening the gaps with the rest of the world.
However development economists and experts from all boards are now approaching the problem from new angles to provide innovative ways to fight African poverty.
Better yet, some African countries are now emerging as real economic powers thanks to better leadership and deals with foreign investors to build infrastructure. Let's see how all that improves our understanding of poverty in Africa, the plague of a continent.
Globalization & causes of poverty in Africa
Better off rich or poor?
Aside from political and social reasons (e.g. corruption, ethnic violence), many economists argue that the absence of economic growth is in part due to a detrimental geography that impacts on the economy.
But in many cases, oil-rich African countries are also more likely to be exploited by other countries or powerful corporations who always find a way to not pay much-needed taxes (billions and billions of dollars).
In most developing countries, disparities pose the problem of redistribution of wealth, but many African countries are simply too poor to redistribute anything. The average income level is sometimes so low that even working people live under poverty. So, how do you fix that?
Free trade agreements against the African continent
International trade policies, for example, are incomparably more important than international aid to end African poverty and help its countries to integrate the global market. Surprising ? Not that much considering the global competition that the continent has to face: not only are the US, the European Union protecting their key industries (especially those that Africa could compete with, like agriculture), but now Asian countries also got in the game, spearheaded by India and China.
With each of them seeking to protect their benefits, the international community should rather give preferential market conditions to poor countries (e.g. for export or agricultural development). This would provide them a path to fast development, and hopefully diffuse the benefits to inner regions. In that way the internal market could also thrive and help alleviate poverty in African countries that are landlocked. Read how African farmers have finally won their case at the World Trade Organization (WTO).
Africa is not poor, others made it that way
"I come from the richest country in the world. It is located in the richest continent in the world. That country is called Sierra Leone." (Mallence Bart-Williams)
Here's the transcript of the beginning of the video and you'll understand very quickly what she's talking about. Read the full transcript of the video here.
"On the surface we are blessed with infinite beauty and abundance of flora and fauna. Producing the most exquisite harvest of coffee, cocoa, fruits, vegetables... and culture. You name it, we've got it.
We also have diverse wildlife and vast marine resources. [...] A true paradise. They also had the first modern university in Africa and prior to that the first university in the world was founded in the kingdom of Timbuktu.
At a deeper level we are blessed with the real treasures that the kings and queens of this world desire. Diamonds and gold are commonly found in people's backyards. You'll also find about 20 precious minerals and recently huge oil reserves have also been discovered.
- Iron ore (the largest in Africa)
- Exquisite timber like mahogany and teak
... all the stuff that goes straight into your computers, laptops and mobile devices.
The West needs Africa's resources desperately to make and power airplanes, computers and engines. But not just the West anymore, pretty much everyone including China are in the same boat."
From dictators established by Western governments, to foreign companies operating all over (I mean "mining the hell out of ") Africa without paying any real tax, nearly everyone is exploiting the continent.
International aid and corruption
Barriers to poverty reduction
So far local governments, international aid and market reforms had only a minimal effect on the population. Consequence: people have had to solve their problems on their own, outside the system. It is only recently that new international policies, such as the United Nations’ Sustainable Development Goal (SDG) in Africa, have stopped overlooking the effect of politics on local economies:
- Transparent and accountable government
- Rule of law
- Public resources management
- Free and fair election
- Active civil society
All of these are now recognized as a vital factor of poverty alleviation. This whole forms what specialists now call “good governance”.
Considering the extent of corruption and violence of local councils and governments, it’s not surprising that a huge part of the African population can only fend for itself most of the time, relying on a makeshift economy. This makes them hard to reach by international aid but at least they have an alternative system to fall back upon: coping through sharing. Not only farmers in rural areas but African urbanites as well manage to avoid the claws of the law. This makes many development policies totally ineffective.
More transparency, less corruption
Another issue is that of international aid. Aid donors obviously want to make sure that their money is put to the right use, rather than to building palaces for individual use. Now how things have changed is that foreign aid has become demand-driven with local communities, governments and NGOs competing to receive the funds. This should help foster competitiveness and efficiency of development projects as well as transparency. In other words it should radically reduce corruption and embezzlement.
This model was field tested and can help avoid the case of the African Millennium Villages, blindly “shooting” money in every direction in a local community, like a crazy action hero who doesn't believe in nuances and complexities of real life.
What is needed is targeted funding that provides new opportunities and incentives for people to participate in the development of their country. Humanitarian aid remains way too opaque, only the most concrete and effective programs should remain. In particular those that help local entrepreneurs, not multinationals.
Geography and regional poverty in Africa
Too poor to redistribute anything?
Recently specialists have increasingly taken into account the role of geography to explain the absence of economic growth and the aggravation of poverty in Africa. Whereas in many developing countries there are disparities that pose the problem of redistribution of wealth, Africa is simply too poor to redistribute anything.
Well that's not totally true. Africa is full of natural resources, but to give just one example many multinational companies that extract these resources don't even pay any taxes to the country where they operate. In other cases, it's simply that the local aristocracy keeps all the revenues to itself.
The African paradox: it's both rich and poor
So poverty in Africa is paradoxical: the continent is made of 54 countries of low population density and rich in natural resources. Of course, as usual the resources are not evenly distributed between regions, countries and within local populations.
The countries are separated into resource-rich and -poor and into coastal and landlocked ones. Across all categories, most countries have remained stuck with a GDP per capita below $2000 for the past six decades.
The need for tailored development
Unlike other continents, a great share of the population in Africa lives in landlocked, resource-scarce countries which accounts for 1% of its overall growth rate. Another consequence of this is that policymakers need to start thinking in terms of context-based development strategies rather than continent-based ones.
In particular concerning the resource-poor landlocked regions which will remain the very core of the African poverty puzzle. A puzzle that year after year became obviously unsolvable in a day. These very countries are the ones that would need a sort of targeted, continuous aid flow in order to steadily raise consumption levels, therefore consistently reducing poorness in Africa. Nevertheless, today's aid flows only focus on short-term emergencies.
- Read about the influence of oil on poverty in Sudan and Darfur
Impact of poverty on health
Almost half of the population in Africa suffers from water-related diseases. On top of insufficient hygiene education, the frequent inundations (and lack of risk prevention) play an important role: in Mozambique over 1 million people were displaced by the floods of 1999/2000 and an unknown number killed.
Diseases: a threat to development
Diseases in Africa – and in particular HIV-AIDS – are another major threat to economic development. As an academic (Whiteside 2002) puts it: “one of the main consequences of the disease is that it impoverishes individuals, households and communities”, thus further entrenching the roots of poverty in Africa.
This is a vicious cycle by which poverty boosts the spread of HIV which in turn increases poverty. The case of the poor in South Africa shows that despite the country's substantial growth, that wealth is still too concentrated in the hands of an "uninfected" minority. That way the gap between the rich and the poor only gets bigger and bigger, making it harder for impoverished populations to catch up with the well-off.
Hygiene and sanitation first
As for basic sanitation and hygiene, it is first and foremost an educational issue. Hygienic habits have consistently prevented millions of deaths across the world in the past decades. And just like in all the countries where it happened, massive full-scale educational campaigns are needed to significantly alleviate poverty in Africa.
- Read about the role of HIV/AIDS in worsening poverty in South Africa
Education and poverty
Education - A neglected cause of poverty
Starting to feel slightly overwhelmed? We're just talking about everyday life poverty here! ... So, not only does proper education help eradicate a great deal of diseases (STIs, sanitation, etc), but there is also a direct link between levels of education and poverty.
Authoritarian rule in most countries has only made the situation worse, deepening both levels of education and poverty in Africa. For that reason, although some argue that authoritarian regimes can better spur development in some cases (China, Singapore,…), but in this case democracy seems more appropriate for the case of Africa.
Is democracy better suited to Africa?
Experts who hold this argument ground it on several factors including: the multi-ethnics nature of most countries (better representation of everyone’s interests), the need for better governance and redistribution of the riches in absence of strong political will, and pervasiveness of corruption that drives people away from the legal and institutional life.
But the experience of democracy in the West has also resulted as we've seen with the protests in 2011 that most of rich countries' wealth eventually ended up in the hands of a very small elite.
Education to gain skills first and foremost
Even though many fancy universities tend to forget it, education is in general about teaching people skills (duh), thereby enhancing productivity, creativity, and exchanges.
Higher education is crucial to bring Africa back into the world system (yes it’s been kind of left aside) and bridge the digital gap with other continents. What we need is then consistent education in ICTs on top of developing the infrastructure (optic fiber, antennas, electricity grids,...) so that people can benefit from an advanced use of ICTs and harness their economic potential.
Obviously on a priority list of fighting poverty in Africa, this comes after meeting the most basic needs such as food, water, health, energy,... How could you possibly charge a computer's battery without electricity in your town? Yet they did that mistake a few years ago and sent thousands of laptops.
- Read about education and fighting poverty in Kenya
Food and water
Hunger, a typical feature of African poverty ?
In the past 30 years only sub-Saharan Africa saw no improvement in fight against malnutrition and hunger in Africa (or several types of malnutrition). Currently there is an estimated 80% of Africans who suffer from hunger, and 30% of whom are children. Despite the current levels of poverty in Nigeria and in Zimbabwe, these countries were part of the group that manage to reduce its underweight population between 1976 and 1995.
On the other hand just as many countries - a dozen - were suffering from sharp rises in under-nutrition. The worst case is that of poverty in Ethiopia which left over a million people underfed. The plight of hunger is undoubtedly one of the most severe effects of poverty in Africa, where it is incomparably harsher than in most other places.
Water, diseases & geography
"All peoples, whatever their stage of development and their social and economic conditions, have the right to have access to drinking water in quantities and of a quality equal to their basic needs". (Action Plan, United Nations Water Conference, Mar del Plata, 1977)
More than 30 years after this statement, more than 50% of Africans still suffer from water-related diseases (cholera, diarrhea). Although the continent is blessed with large rivers such as the Congo, the Nile, the Zambezi and the Niger, uneven geographical distribution causes sharp shortages of water in Africa. History has shown that despite technical, financial, economic and institutional support in water-related projects, poor governance has been a major factor in ruining those efforts and resources.
The end of the tunnel?
The causes and effects of poverty in Africa are fueling a seriously vicious cycle that stops Africans from getting the most basic services. It affects simple water supply, sanitation, health care and education in incredibly diverse ways.
Ultimately it becomes so all-pervasive that it overwhelms the application of the very best practices drawn from past lessons. The way out of poverty in Africa is therefore hardly imaginable without the constructive and appropriate help and cooperation of the international community, along with (increasingly) that of private businesses from other countries.
- A Pro-Poor Urban Agenda for Africa: Clarifying Ecological and Development Issues for Poor and Vulnerable Populations, Joel Bolnick et al., Human Settlements Discussion Paper Series IIED 2006
- Africa's Counter-Cyclical Policy Responses to the Crisis, Louis Kasekende et al., Journal of Globalization and Development 2010
- The African Millennium Villages, Pedro Sanchez et al., National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America 2007
- Education, Democracy and Poverty Reduction in Africa, Clive Harber, Comparative Education 2002
- Challenges to Meet: Food and Nutrition Security in the New Millennium, Michael Lipton, Proceedings of the Nutrition Society 2001
- Globalization, Growth, Inequality, and Poverty in Africa: A Macroeconomic Perspective, Jeffery I. Round, The Poor under Globalization in Asia, Latin America, and Africa 2010
- Governance and Poverty Reduction in Africa, Goran Hyden, National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America 2007
- ICT & Education in Africa: Partnership, Practice & Knowledge Sharing, Tim Unwin, Review of African Political Economy 2004
- The New Economic History of Africa, A.G. Hopkins, Journal of African History 2009
- Nutrition Security, Livelihoods and HIV/AIDS: Implications for Research Among Farm Worker Households in South Africa, S Lemke, Public Health Nutrition 2004
- Epidemiological and Nutrition Transition in Developing Countries: Impact on Human Health and Development, Paul Amuna and Francis B. Zotor, Proceedings of the Nutrition Society 2008
- Poverty and HIV/AIDS in Africa, Alan Whiteside, Third World Quarterly 2002
- Poverty Reduction in Africa, Paul Collier, National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America 2007
- Mysteries and Myths: De Soto, Proverty and Poverty in South Africa, Rosalie Kingwill et al., IIED 2005
- Does Living in an Urban Environment Confer Advantages for Childhood Nutritional Status? Analysis of Disparities in Nutritional Status by Wealth and Residence in Angola, Central African Republic and Senegal, Gina Kennedy et al., Public Health Nutrition 2005
- Sierra Leone – Investing in Nutrition to Reduce Poverty: a Call for Action, Victor M Aguayo et al., Public Health Nutrition 2003
- Responding to the Crisis in Sub-Saharan Africa: the Role of Nutrition, Mickey Chopra and Ian Darnton-Hill, Public Health Nutrition 2006
- Water for Basic Needs, Len Abrams, World Health Organisation 2001
- The Facts on Water in Africa, WWF 2002
- Water Sector Governance in Africa, Water Partnership Program (WPP) of the African Development Bank 2008